By Michael Bilotta, President, Gladstone Associates
Follow Michael Bilotta on LinkedIn
Gladstone’s Senior Managing Director / President – Talent Search Steve Clark asked Jason Gordo a direct question on The Hunter this summer. After years of RIA multiples climbing from five and six times EBITDA to eleven, twelve, fifteen, and higher, does this revert to a mean at some point? Gordo runs Modern Wealth, one of the fastest-growing acquirers in the country, and he gave an answer more candid than most operators would risk on the record. He said, “I think valuations are really high, and I can’t see them going any higher.”
His answer addressed three issues:
- Advisors see robust multiples in the headlines and may sometimes think they deserve the exact same enterprise value.
- Net new asset growth is the critical driver of valuations, but many firms aren’t succeeding here.
- The multiple needs enough room for the aggregator to create more value when they sell the platform.
Today, we’re looking at all three statements and applying them to RIA founders considering a sale in the next 12 to 36 months.
If you are wondering about what your firm might be worth, get an idea with our free valuation calculator based on real industry inputs.
Do Advisors Have Unrealistic Expectations Around Valuations?
The first issue is what I hear from well-intentioned owners almost every week. They read about an astronomic multiple in the trade press, and they assume it describes them or at least something in that ballpark. The fact is, we will unlock great value for our sellers, but we help them understand market realities.
“Elite firms deserve a premium value,” Jason told Steve. “Everybody thinks they’re elite. They’re not.” Growth, culture, retention, and leadership depth matter more than size, in his view, and not every $500 million or billion-dollar firm has earned the multiple it thinks it has. In my conversations with buyers, I would agree. Scale is no longer a primary driver of your valuation, as many of these aggregators have already built much of the scale they need. Now they are prioritizing talent and capabilities, especially beyond founders.
Jason’s take was echoed by our “Meet the Buyers” panel at our annual M&A Conference.
- Brian Keller of Dakota Wealth said that he doesn’t see multiples having enough space to keep expanding. Premium valuations are increasingly reserved for robust growth firms with founders who aren’t ready to exit. There’s still enough appetite to get into the industry that valuations remain high, but selectivity is rapidly increasing.
- Sarah Baker of Allworth Financial agreed. She said they are also expecting a growing trend of corrections in the coming year or so.
- Derek Bruton of Modern Wealth acknowledged that while making predictions can feel impossible, there are more businesses selling than ever, shifting more discretion to the buyers.
The barbell is the story. The high end keeps getting more valuable, and the undifferentiated middle does not move. The headline multiple you read about belongs to the high end of that barbell, where the most scalable firms reside, and most sellers are not sitting where they think they are on it.
Valuation is a Net New Assets Growth Question
Jason’s second point around NNA is where I want to spend the most time, because the data backs him up firmly. The numbers are brutal. Marketing Maven Greg Bogich, CEO of AcquireUp, moderating a growth panel at our conference this spring, put a number on it in front of the room: something like 10 percent of firms grow north of 4 percent a year!
Bob Oros, who spent six and a half years running Hightower before his current role at PPB, did not push back on that figure. He reviewed 300 to 400 acquisition opportunities a year at Hightower, and the single most common reason to pass was lack of same-store sales growth. His framing of this industry as a large 60/40 index fund, where he could map every point the S&P moved to his own EBITDA almost exactly, is why buyers have stopped giving credit for growth that just tracks the market. If the market did the work, the market gets the credit, not you.
Oros made a second point that fewer people talk about. Custodial referral programs carry a real cost of client acquisition, lower attached profit, and less client stickiness, and buyers are starting to value that revenue differently than growth from your own effort. A firm living off one channel gets priced differently than a firm with several.
Cynthia Styles, one of Gladstone’s senior analysts, said that the spread between a growing firm and a stagnant one runs roughly three to four turns of multiple. Four turns is not a rounding error in your outcome!
Aggregators Have a Cap on Multiples – It’s This
The third issue is the one sellers understand least, because it requires thinking about the deal from the buyer’s side of the table instead of your own.
The large integrated RIA platforms trade in the 20+ times multiple range.s. A buyer entering the market today at mid-double-digit multiples is playing an arbitrage game. For much private equity money, that is the entire transaction. They are not buying your clients. They are buying the spread between what they pay you and what the platform is worth when they eventually sell it.
The simple summary explains a natural cap on retail acquisitions we see in sell-side advisory. There needs to be enough arbitrage for all the players involved in the second sale.
What Does This Mean For Your Valuation
So if you are thinking about a sale sometime in the next 12 to 36 months, here is what those three issues mean for what you do between now and then.
Understand your valuation before a buyer tells you a number. Our bespoke valuation process is among the best in the industry, and we can help you understand your current valuation, as well as strategies to grow ahead of your transaction.
Understand the buyers in the market. Whether you’re exploring aggregators or other types of buyers, we track over 60 active buyers in our proprietary database. We can help you filter the short list of potential buyers who best align with your expectations around economics, continuity, culture, and support.
Work with our sell-side advisory program. This is the most significant financial transaction of your life, and it’s likely your first time going through it. Every buyer is pitching you–who is looking out for your best interests? That’s the role Gladstone plays. We identify, vet, and advocate alongside you to achieve an optimal outcome. In our last 25 transactions, our average RIA was around $950M in AUM, and we have a long track record of sellers who had excellent experiences.
To explore how we serve firms like yours, explore our M&A capabilities here.
Michael Bilotta is the President of Gladstone Associates, Gladstone Group’s M&A advisory practice. He has advised on dozens of RIA and wealth management transactions for 20 years. Reach him at mbilotta@gstonellc.com.